Beyond the Headlines: The Smart Investor's Guide to Division 296

If you've been following the super changes, you might be feeling overwhelmed by all the noise about Division 296. Let's dive deeper into what savvy investors need to know, and more importantly, what they need to do.

The $3 Million Question Everyone's Getting Wrong

Let’s clear this up: it’s not a 30% tax, and it’s not a tax on your whole super balance. The $3 million figure is simply a threshold, the point where a portion of your super earnings start attracting extra tax. Only the earnings on the part of your balance above $3 million are affected, and even then, the extra tax is 15%, not 30%. Big difference.

Breaking Down the Real Numbers

Let's get specific about how this works:

• Your first $3 million in super? Business as usual

• Earnings on amounts above $3 million? Add 15% tax

But here's where it gets interesting...

The Hidden Opportunity Most Are Missing

A lot of headlines make it sound like super balances over $3 million are suddenly taxed at 30% on the entire balance. That’s not quite how it works.

Here’s the real story:

• Earnings on your super up to $3 million stay taxed as normal, often 0% if you’re in pension phase, or 15% in accumulation.

• Only the earnings linked to the portion above $3 million attract the extra Division 296 tax.

• That extra tax is 15%, meaning a maximum of 30% tax on those earnings.

• However, unlike normal super tax, this new tax also applies to unrealised gains. So, you could end up paying tax on paper gains even if you haven’t sold the investment.

Even with these changes, super can remain as one of the most tax-effective ways to invest. Outside of super, the same earnings could be taxed at up to 47% at the top marginal tax rate. But it's important to plan, because the rules around unrealised gains make this very different from how tax normally works.

How the Earnings Are Calculated for Division 296

One of the more confusing parts of Division 296 is how they work out the "earnings" that the extra tax applies to. Unlike normal tax on investment earnings, they don’t just look at income and capital gains you’ve realised. Instead, they calculate earnings using a formula based on your super balance:

Earnings 

=

Total Super Balance on 30 June this year 

– 

Total Super Balance on 30 June last year

 +

 any withdrawals you’ve made during the year
- 

any personal contributions you’ve made during the year

This means:

• It captures both realised and unrealised gains (even if you haven’t sold anything).

• Withdrawals are added back (so pulling money out doesn’t reduce the earnings calculation).

• New contributions are excluded from earnings (so you’re not taxed on money you’ve just put in).

Once your earnings are calculated, the ATO works out what portion relates to your balance above $3 million. It’s only that portion of earnings that gets the extra 15% Division 296 tax.

Strategy Over Panic: The Smart Money Approach

Instead of rushing to pull money out of super (which we're seeing far too often), consider these strategic approaches:

1. Spouse Balancing Strategies

   • Use spouse contribution splitting to even up balances and keep both members under $3 million.

   • Withdrawal and recontribution strategies can also help shift balances between spouses where age, eligibility, and contribution caps allow.

2. Alternative Ownership Structures

   • For future investments, consider directing new investments into family trusts, companies, or personal names where appropriate.

   • Consider investment bonds for long-term wealth accumulation. Earnings are taxed inside the bond at 30%, and withdrawals may be tax-free after 10 years if managed correctly.

   • Review asset location between super and non-super to help manage future growth inside super.

3. Growth Management

   • Certain investment choices may help reduce volatility or smooth growth, limiting large unrealised gains that feed into the Division 296 formula.

   • Use pension drawdowns or partial lump sum withdrawals where appropriate to help manage balances.

The key is: don’t act emotionally. With careful planning, there are still ways to grow wealth tax-effectively, even with the new rules.

The Calculation That Changes Everything

Let's put some real numbers on this:

For $4 million in super:

• The fund earns 7% for the year, so total growth is $280,000.

• Division 296 only applies to the portion of earnings linked to the balance above $3 million — in this case, 25% of the total balance.

• That means $70,000 of earnings are subject to the extra tax ($280,000 × 25%).

• The extra tax is 15% of that, which equals $10,500.

Now compare this to investing the same funds personally:

• Part of the return would be taxable income, part would be capital gains taxed when realised.

• Even allowing for capital gains discounts and deferred tax, the personal tax rate on long-term returns could easily average between 25%–35% for high income earners.

• That still leaves super as the more tax-effective structure for most high-balance investors — even after Division 296 applies.

What the Smart Money is Doing

The sophisticated investors we work with aren’t rushing to pull money out of super. Instead, they’re taking a more strategic approach:

• Waiting for the final legislation before making any major structural changes

• Using spouse contribution splitting and withdrawal/recontribution strategies to better balance super balances across the household

• Reviewing ownership structures for new investments, including family trusts, investment bonds, or companies where appropriate

• Managing growth inside super to limit large unrealised gains feeding into the Division 296 calculation

• Keeping the long-term benefits of super in focus, rather than reacting emotionally to short-term rule changes

The Three Questions You Need to Answer

1. Is your super balance already above $3 million — or likely to grow above that in future?

2. How much growth (both income and capital gains) are you expecting on your super over time?

3. How would the extra Division 296 tax compare to your personal tax rate if you invested the same money outside super?

Only by looking at both your current position and where you're heading can you make the right long-term decisions about managing Division 296.

Your Action Plan

1. Immediate Steps

   • Calculate your projected super balance

   • Understand how Division 296 earnings are calculated

   • Review your household super balances, contributions, and withdrawal options

2. Medium-Term Strategy

   • Explore spouse balancing strategies (contribution splitting, withdrawal & recontribution)

   • Review new investments and ownership structures (family trusts, investment bonds, companies)

3. Long-Term Positioning

   • Build a broader family wealth strategy that looks beyond just super

   • Incorporate intergenerational planning and estate considerations

   • Maintain flexibility to adjust as legislation evolves

The Bottom Line

Division 296 isn't a reason to abandon super, it's a prompt to be more strategic about how you use it. The smart money isn't running from super; it's getting smarter about how to use it effectively.

Want to turn Division 296 from a challenge into an opportunity? Let's develop your strategic response.

Find out more BOOK A CALL HERE